GPXtoGPS GPXtoGPS and BaseCamp compared
GPXtoGPS and Garmin BaseCamp compared
GPXtoGPS does the jobs most people kept BaseCamp for: planning a trip on a Garmin map, sending routes and maps to the GPS, and keeping the tracks it records. It runs natively on Apple silicon Macs and on Windows. It does not read Garmin's own locked maps, and some of BaseCamp's planning options are not there yet.
By Rohan, who makes GPXtoGPS · checked 16 November 2026
Side by side
GPXtoGPS does itIt does not, or not yet
| What | Garmin BaseCamp | GPXtoGPS |
|---|---|---|
| On your computer | ||
| Runs on Apple silicon Macs | Only through Rosetta 2 (it is an Intel program) | Yes, natively; macOS 14.5 or later |
| Runs on Intel Macs | Yes | No |
| Runs on Windows | Yes, on Intel and AMD; on Arm PCs only through emulation | Yes: Windows 10 and 11, with its own build for Arm PCs |
| New versions | None planned, Garmin says; the last Mac version is from March 2023 | In beta, updated often; the app updates itself |
| Planning a trip | ||
| Plan a trip of several days on a Garmin map | Yes | Yes: places, stays and nights, with the distance, driving time and clock times of each day |
| Work out the days from the hours you want to drive | Yes | Yes |
| Plan on OpenStreetMap Garmin maps and Tracks4Africa | Yes | Yes |
| Plan on Garmin's own maps (City Navigator, TopoActive) | Yes | No: they are locked and cannot be read |
| Find a place by name | Yes, including addresses on City Navigator | Yes: the map's own places (towns, campsites, fuel and more); no street-address search |
| View a Garmin map on the computer | Yes | Yes: drawn by the app with its places, offline too |
| Drag the planned line onto another road | Yes | Yes: the day goes through a silent pin where you let go |
| Heights along a planned route | Yes, on maps with height data | Rough, from the map's contour lines |
| Save a trip as GPX | Yes | Yes: one file, or a file each day |
| The fastest or the shortest route | Yes | Yes, by car: TRIP SETTINGS → THE WAY |
| Avoidances, walking and cycling profiles | Yes | Not yet |
| The GPS | ||
| Send routes to the GPS | Yes | Yes, and afterwards it checks the GPS's version against your line |
| Turn a GPX track from another planner into a route | Yes, one track at a time | Yes, every track in the file at once, with your named stops kept and silent pins on your line |
| Install a downloaded map on the GPS | With Garmin's separate MapManager and MapInstall | Drop the download on the app |
| Your tracks | ||
| Keep the tracks the GPS recorded | Yes, in its own library | Yes, as plain GPX files in a folder you choose, by date or in groups |
| A table of tracks with their figures | Yes | Yes: points, times, moving time, length, climb, speeds and area; sort, total, copy or save as CSV |
| Height and speed graph | Yes | Yes, both ways: the pointer on the graph shows the spot on the map, and on the map the graph |
| Trim, split and join tracks | Yes | Yes, saved as new tracks; the originals are never changed |
| Move, add and delete a track's points | Yes | Yes, with undo; saved as a new track |
| Save tracks as GPX | Yes | Yes: one file or a file each, also files on the GPS |
| Garmin watches | ||
| Send courses to a Garmin watch | No: that is Garmin Connect's job | Yes, over the USB cable; the watch's outdoor activities come into the history |
| Also | ||
| Waypoints of your own, with symbols | Yes | Yes: places with a name, symbol and note, sent to the GPS as saved places; the waypoints in a GPX file are not brought in |
| Geotagged photos, BirdsEye imagery | Yes | No |
| Price | ||
| Price | Free | Free during the beta; pricing to be confirmed |
BaseCamp for Windows is another case: it still runs there, and the Windows page says where GPXtoGPS fits in. BaseCamp's column describes version 4.8.13 for Mac (Garmin's download page: March 2023, for Intel Macs). Garmin's word on new versions is on its forum, Apple's on Rosetta 2 in its note. Why its future on the Mac is short: what is happening to BaseCamp.
Where GPXtoGPS goes further
- It checks the result. After the GPS has imported a route, the app compares it with your line and says whether the Garmin kept to it.
- It is careful with the GPS. Maps are checked before they are sent, anything replaced is backed up first, and the Garmin's own files are never edited.
- Your data stays plain. Tracks are GPX files and trips are files in a folder, not a database only one program can open.
Where BaseCamp is still ahead
If you plan on City Navigator, search for street addresses, or plan walking and cycling routes with their own profiles, BaseCamp does that today and GPXtoGPS does not. Many people will run both for a while. An unlocked OpenStreetMap map of the same area gives the planner roads to work with; the GPS then drives the planned line on whichever map it has.
Other ways to replace BaseCamp
GPXtoGPS is one of several. Garmin's own Express, Connect, Explore and Tread each take over a part of what BaseCamp did (updates, courses for watches and handhelds, motorcycle routes); QMapShack plans and edits on a computer, GPX.Studio and MyRoute-app plan in the browser and leave you a GPX file to put on the GPS. In one line each, with what each does and does not do: on a Mac and on Windows.
Questions
Is GPXtoGPS a full replacement for BaseCamp?
For planning trips on unlocked maps, sending routes and maps to the GPS and keeping tracks, yes. GPXtoGPS does not read Garmin's locked maps, search street addresses, or offer walking and cycling profiles and avoidances yet.
Can I use both?
Yes: GPXtoGPS and BaseCamp can be installed side by side, as long as BaseCamp still opens on your Mac. Quit one before the other uses the GPS: only one program can hold it at a time.